Skip to main content
Skip to main content
Advanced

Dismissal Precedence (Which Way Out Counts)

Also known as: bowled takes precedence, caught takes precedence, out two ways on one ball, which dismissal counts, stumped or run out which applies

Definition

When a batter could be out in more than one way on the same ball, the Laws pick one. Bowled beats every other method (Law 32.2). Caught beats every method except bowled (Law 33.5). A striker who is out stumped is not also run out (Law 38.2.2.1).

Law 32.2 says the striker is out bowled if a fair delivery breaks their wicket, even if another dismissal could also be given. Law 33.5 says that if the striker is not bowled but the catch rules are met, they are out caught, whatever else happened. Law 38.2.2.1 says a striker who is out stumped is not out run out. Stumping needs the striker not to be attempting a run, and the keeper to act without another fielder.

Timing matters as well. Under Law 20.1.1.3, the ball is dead from the instant of the incident that causes a dismissal. Anything that happens afterwards on that ball does not count. So a ball that breaks the wicket and then flies to slip is bowled, and the catch is irrelevant.

The choice changes the record. A run out, for example, is never credited to the bowler (Law 38.6). It also matters in reviews. Under ICC playing conditions, if a review leaves the batter out by a different mode, it still counts as unsuccessful.

Tips by skill level

Beginner tip

In the scorebook, record the dismissal the umpire gives. If you are unsure, ask the umpire at the next break.

Advanced note

Under ICC DRS, if the third umpire finds the batter out by a different mode from the one given, the review still counts as unsuccessful (Appendix D 3.6.5).

Example

A delivery clips off stump, removing a bail, and flies to first slip, who catches it. The batter is out bowled, not caught, because bowled takes precedence.

Why it matters

The mode of dismissal decides who gets credit for the wicket and how the scorebook reads. In reviews, it can decide whether a team loses a review.

Common mistakes

  • Recording a ball that hit the stumps and was then caught as caught. It is bowled.
  • Thinking LBW wins when the ball deflects off the pad onto the stumps. That is bowled.
  • Calling it a run out when the keeper breaks the wicket and the striker was not attempting a run. That is stumped, as long as it was not a no-ball.

Frequently asked questions

If the ball hits the stumps and is then caught, is it bowled or caught?

Bowled. Law 32.2 says bowled takes precedence over any other method of dismissal.

Is it stumped or run out if the keeper breaks the wicket?

If the striker was not attempting a run, the keeper acted without another fielder, and it was not a no-ball, it is stumped. If the striker was attempting a run, it is run out.

Sources

Still have a question about Dismissal Precedence (Which Way Out Counts)? Ask SwingVantage

Ready to work on your own batting?

This term is background, not something video measures. Film one shot to find the one thing to work on first — free to start.