Skip to main content
Skip to main content
Advanced

Reasonable Judgment Standard (Rule 1.3b(2))

Also known as: reasonable judgment, reasonable judgement rule, estimating where the ball crossed, video shows my drop was wrong, rule 1.3b(2)

Definition

When the Rules ask you to estimate a spot, line or edge, your reasonable judgment is accepted if you made a careful effort. That stands even if video later shows you were wrong.

Many Rules need a location that cannot be measured exactly. Examples include where a ball last crossed a penalty area edge, or where a relief area ends. Others are the spot to replace a ball, which area of the course a ball lies in, and whether it touches an abnormal condition.

Rule 1.3b(2) says such calls should be made promptly and with care. If you do what can reasonably be expected to get it right, your judgment is accepted. That holds even if video or other information later proves it wrong. This protects players from penalties found only by close replay after the stroke.

The protection ends before the stroke. If you learn the call was wrong before you play, you must correct it under Rule 14.5. For example, someone may find your ball in a red penalty area. It may show the ball crossed 20 yards nearer the hole than your estimate. You must then redo the relief from the right point. When an estimate is a guess between equal choices, the Rules give tie-breaks. For example, an unfound ball equally likely to be in a penalty area or in nearby ground under repair needs penalty area relief.

Tips by skill level

Beginner tip

Take a moment, walk to the area, and ask your playing partners what they saw. Then commit.

Advanced note

Note how you made the estimate. If questioned later, showing your process supports that it was reasonable.

Example

A player estimates where her ball crossed into a creek, checking with her group, and drops. TV replay later shows the crossing was a yard away. Her careful estimate stands and there is no penalty.

Why it matters

It lets you act with confidence on estimates. It rewards care rather than perfect precision.

Common mistakes

  • Rushing an estimate without walking to the spot or asking others
  • Playing on after learning the estimate was clearly wrong
  • Assuming video can always overturn a careful estimate

Frequently asked questions

Can I be penalized if video shows I dropped in the wrong spot?

Not if you made a reasonable, careful estimate. The Rules accept it even if video later shows it was wrong.

What if I find out my estimate was wrong before I hit?

Then you must correct the mistake before making the stroke.

Sources

Still have a question about Reasonable Judgment Standard (Rule 1.3b(2))? Ask SwingVantage

Related guides & benchmarks

Ready to work on your own swing?

This term is background, not something video measures. Film one swing to find the one thing to work on first — free to start.