Soft Signal (Former DRS Rule)
Also known as: soft signal in cricket, soft signal abolished, what was the soft signal, umpire soft signal, soft signal rule
The soft signal was the on-field umpire's initial out or not-out decision, shown to the third umpire when referring a catch. If the replays were inconclusive, it stood. The ICC removed it from its playing conditions at the start of June 2023.
Older ICC playing conditions defined the soft signal as the bowler's end umpire telling the third umpire their initial on-field decision before an umpire review. When both on-field umpires needed help with a catch, the bowler's end umpire made a TV-screen sign. They then gave a soft signal of out or not out, with the hands close to the chest. If the third umpire found the replay evidence inconclusive, that on-field call stood.
The ICC removed the soft signal at the start of June 2023. The ICC's Men's Cricket Committee concluded that soft signals were unnecessary and at times confusing. The ICC said on-field umpires would consult the TV umpire before any decision is taken.
Under the current ICC conditions, the bowler's end umpire first consults the striker's end umpire on a fair catch or bump ball. If they still need help, they consult the third umpire, who decides whether the batter was caught. For player reviews, inconclusive evidence still leaves the on-field decision standing.
Tips by skill level
If you hear commentators mention a soft signal, they are describing the rule before June 2023.
Removing the soft signal changed umpire-referred catches, not player reviews. On a player review, inconclusive evidence still leaves the on-field decision standing (Appendix D 3.3.6).
Example
Before June 2023, an umpire unsure about a low catch at slip would give a soft signal of out before sending it upstairs. If the replays could not show the ball touching the ground, the batter was out. Now the third umpire decides from the replays.
Why it matters
Older highlights and debates often mention it. Knowing it has gone explains how low catches are decided now.
Common mistakes
- Thinking the soft signal still applies in ICC international cricket. It was removed in June 2023.
- Thinking it was a final decision. It only stood when the replays were inconclusive.
- Assuming every competition works the same way. Check the playing conditions of the event you are watching.
Frequently asked questions
What was the soft signal in cricket?
It was the on-field umpire's initial out or not-out call, signalled to the third umpire when a catch was referred. If the replays were inconclusive, it stood.
When was the soft signal scrapped?
The ICC removed it from its playing conditions at the start of June 2023. On-field umpires now consult the third umpire before a decision is taken.
Sources
- ICC Men's T20 World Cup 2022 Playing Conditions, Appendix A 5.10 (Soft Signal) and Appendix D 2.2.2 (soft signal when referring a catch)
- ICC news, "Why soft signal wasn't used to decide Shubman Gill wicket" (10 June 2023)
- ICC Men's Test Match Playing Conditions (effective Oct 2026), Appendix D, paragraphs 2.2.1 to 2.2.3 (caught decisions), p. 90; paragraph 3.3.6 (inconclusive evidence), p. 94
Related terms
- Third Umpire (TV Umpire)The third umpire is the off-field official who watches TV replays in international cricket. They rule on run outs, stumpings, boundaries and other referrals from the on-field umpires, handle DRS reviews, and stand by as the emergency on-field umpire.
- DRS (Decision Review System)DRS lets players ask the third umpire to review an on-field decision on whether a batter is out. Only the batter given out can review an out, and only the fielding captain can review a not out. The request is a 'T' sign within 15 seconds. DRS comes from ICC playing conditions, not the Laws of Cricket.
- CaughtCaught is a way of being out in cricket. The batter is out when a fielder catches the ball before it touches the ground, after it has come off the bat or a glove on the hand holding the bat (Laws 33.1 and 5.6).
- Bump BallA bump ball is a ball the batter hits into the ground straight away, which then bounces up and is caught. It can look like a clean catch, but it is not out, because the ball touched the ground first.
- Benefit of the Doubt (Doubt Goes to the Batter)In cricket, the benefit of the doubt goes to the batter. Under Law 31.6, if an umpire is still unsure after consulting the other umpire, the decision must be not out.
- Fair Catch (Law 33.2)A fair catch is one the Laws accept as a dismissal. Under Law 33.2 the ball can be held in a hand that touches the ground, hugged to the body, or lodged in a fielder's protective gear. It may also rebound off the stumps, an umpire or another player first.
Available in other languages
Ready to work on your own batting?
This term is background, not something video measures. Film one shot to find the one thing to work on first — free to start.