Benefit of the Doubt (Doubt Goes to the Batter)
Also known as: benefit of the doubt, benefit of the doubt to the batter, doubt goes to the batter, if in doubt not out, umpires consulting on a decision
In cricket, the benefit of the doubt goes to the batter. Under Law 31.6, if an umpire is still unsure after consulting the other umpire, the decision must be not out.
Law 31.6 sets the process. Each umpire answers appeals on matters in their own area. If an umpire is unsure about a point the other umpire was better placed to see, they consult on that point of fact. Then they give the decision. If doubt still remains after consulting, the decision shall be not out.
This is where the saying comes from. The fielding side has to convince the umpire. A batter does not have to prove they were not out. It applies to every kind of dismissal decided on appeal.
Replays change who gets the benefit. In a DRS review, the on-field decision stands unless the third umpire can decide with a high degree of confidence that it should change (Appendix D 3.3.6). So with DRS, an unclear replay leaves an out decision as out. For a boundary check, unclear TV evidence means no boundary is given (Appendix D 2.3.3).
Tips by skill level
As a fielder, appeal when you believe the batter is out, not just because it was close.
Before a DRS review, weigh the on-field call. An inconclusive replay leaves it in place, whichever way it went.
Example
A run-out appeal is very close at the bowler's end. The bowler's end umpire asks the square-leg umpire, who also cannot be sure. The decision is not out.
Why it matters
It explains why genuinely unclear calls are given not out. It also shows why the on-field call matters so much once replays are used.
Common mistakes
- Treating a 50-50 call as a coin flip. If real doubt remains, it is not out.
- Assuming the same rule applies in a DRS review. There, the on-field call stands unless replays show it was wrong.
- Expecting umpires to consult on every decision. They consult on points the other umpire saw better.
Frequently asked questions
Does the benefit of the doubt go to the batter in cricket?
Yes, under the Laws. Law 31.6 says that if doubt remains after the umpires consult, the decision shall be not out.
Does the batter get the benefit of the doubt with DRS?
Not in the same way. Under ICC rules the on-field decision stands if the replays are inconclusive, so an out decision stays out.
Sources
- MCC Laws of Cricket, 2017 Code 4th Edition (2026), Law 31.5-31.6 (answering appeals; consultation by umpires; doubt means Not out), pp. 101-102
- ICC Men's Test Match Playing Conditions (effective Oct 2026), Appendix D para 2.3.3 (inconclusive boundary evidence: no boundary), p. 91; para 3.3.6 (inconclusive replays: on-field decision stands), p. 94
Related terms
- Appeal (How's That?)An appeal is the fielding side asking an umpire whether a batter is out, usually by calling "How's that?". Under Law 31.1, an umpire may not give a batter out unless a fielder appeals.
- Umpire (On-Field Umpires)Umpires are the two officials who control a cricket match, one at each end. Under Law 2 they apply the Laws impartially, answer appeals, and are the sole judges of fair play and of whether conditions are fit.
- DRS (Decision Review System)DRS lets players ask the third umpire to review an on-field decision on whether a batter is out. Only the batter given out can review an out, and only the fielding captain can review a not out. The request is a 'T' sign within 15 seconds. DRS comes from ICC playing conditions, not the Laws of Cricket.
- Third Umpire (TV Umpire)The third umpire is the off-field official who watches TV replays in international cricket. They rule on run outs, stumpings, boundaries and other referrals from the on-field umpires, handle DRS reviews, and stand by as the emergency on-field umpire.
- Plumb (Plumb LBW)Plumb LBW means an LBW so clear that nobody can argue with it. The ball pitched in line, hit the batter in line with the stumps and was going on to hit them. Batters given out plumb usually walk off, because a review would almost never save them.
Available in other languages
Ready to work on your own batting?
This term is background, not something video measures. Film one shot to find the one thing to work on first — free to start.