Fourth-Out Appeal (Apparent Fourth Out)
Also known as: apparent fourth out, fourth out rule, appeal after the third out, four outs in an inning
A fourth-out appeal is an appeal made after the third out to take a run off the board. If a runner left early or missed a base, the defense can still appeal him. The umpire may then recognize an apparent fourth out that replaces the third.
MLB Rule 5.09(c) says appeal plays may require the umpire to recognize an apparent fourth out. Suppose the third out is made during a play, and an appeal is then upheld on another runner. The appeal decision takes precedence in deciding which out ended the inning. If there is more than one appeal on that play, the defense may choose the out that helps it most.
This matters because some third outs cancel runs and others do not. Take one out, with runners on first and third. A fly ball is caught for the second out. The runner from third tags and scores before the runner from first is doubled off for the third out. That out was not a force, so the run would count. But if the runner from third left early, the defense can appeal. His out replaces the third out, and his run comes off the board.
Little League's FAQ notes the ball stays live after the third out. The chance to appeal lasts until all defensive players leave fair territory. MLB sets the deadline when the pitcher and all infielders have left fair territory. The play is easy to miss, because players tend to run off the field on the third out.
Tips by skill level
If a run scored on a play that ended the inning, ask whether the runner left early or missed a base. If so, appeal before you leave the field.
When two appeals are possible on an inning-ending play, choose the out that wipes out the most runs. MLB's rule lets the defense pick.
Example
One out, runners on first and third. The batter flies out to center. The runner from third leaves early and scores. The center fielder throws to first and doubles off the other runner for the third out. Before leaving the field, the defense throws to third and appeals. The umpire upholds it, and the run does not count.
Why it matters
It can erase a run the scoreboard already shows. Defenses that know it stay on the field one play longer.
Common mistakes
- Running off the field the moment the third out is made, with an appeal still open.
- Thinking nothing more can happen once three outs are recorded.
- Appealing without a real violation. The appeal must name a runner who actually left early or missed a base.
Frequently asked questions
Can there be four outs in an inning?
Not really, but the umpire can recognize an apparent fourth out on appeal. The appeal out replaces the earlier third out so that a run does not count.
Is the ball dead after the third out?
No. Little League's FAQ notes the ball stays live, so the defense can still appeal until its players leave fair territory.
Sources
Related terms
- Appeal PlayAn appeal play is the defense's claim that a runner broke a base-running rule, such as missing a base or leaving early on a caught fly. The umpire rules only when the defense appeals. If he upholds it, the runner is out.
- Time Play (Run Scoring on the Third Out)A time play is a play where the third out is not a force out. As a result, a run counts if the runner touched home before the out was made. The umpire must judge which happened first.
- Tag UpTagging up means a baserunner returns to and touches their current base as a fly ball is caught, then takes off toward the next base — the legal method of advancing on a caught fly.
- Missing a Base (Touching Bases in Order)Runners must touch first, second, third and home in order, and retouch them in reverse order if they must go back. A runner who misses a base can be called out on appeal, even on a home run.
- Sacrifice FlyA sacrifice fly is a fly ball out, hit deep enough to the outfield. It allows a runner on third base to tag up and score after the catch. It does not count as an official at-bat and does not hurt the hitter's batting average.
Available in other languages
Related guides & benchmarks
Ready to work on your own swing?
This term is background, not something video measures. Film one swing to find the one thing to work on first — free to start.