Skip to main content
Skip to main content
Intermediate

Appeal Play

Also known as: appeal plays, appealing a missed base, appeal for leaving early, live ball appeal

Definition

An appeal play is the defense's claim that a runner broke a base-running rule, such as missing a base or leaving early on a caught fly. The umpire rules only when the defense appeals. If he upholds it, the runner is out.

MLB Rule 5.09(c) lists four appeal outs. A runner leaves his base before a fly ball is caught and does not retouch. A runner misses a base while advancing or returning. A batter-runner overruns first and does not return at once. A runner misses home plate and makes no attempt to go back. In each case the defense tags the runner or the base and asks for a ruling. Batting out of order is also settled by appeal.

The appeal must be clear. A spoken request, or an act that plainly shows the intent, will do. A fielder who just happens to step on the base with the ball has not appealed. Time is not out during an appeal, so runners may advance at their own risk. The appeal must come before the next pitch or any play or attempted play. If the play ended the inning, it must come before the pitcher and all infielders leave fair territory.

There are limits. If the defense throws the ball out of play while appealing, it cannot appeal that runner at that base again. A balk during an appeal counts as a play. Little League allows several appeals at once, on one runner at different bases or on different runners at one base. Its FAQ adds that a pitcher on the rubber may step and throw to a base to appeal.

Tips by skill level

Beginner tip

If you think a runner missed a base, get the ball, touch that base and tell the umpire clearly what you are appealing.

Advanced note

On the last out of an inning, keep the infielders in fair territory until the appeal is made. Once they all leave, the chance is gone.

Example

Runner on first, one out. The batter doubles to the gap. The runner scores but cuts inside second base without touching it. After the play, the pitcher steps off and throws to the shortstop at second. The shortstop touches the base and tells the umpire the runner missed it. The umpire agrees and calls the runner out.

Why it matters

Umpires do not call these outs on their own. A defense that watches the bases and appeals correctly can take runs away.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming the umpire will call a missed base without an appeal.
  • Throwing the next pitch before appealing. The chance is gone once the pitch is made.
  • Throwing the ball away on the appeal. That ends the right to appeal that runner at that base.
  • Leaving the field before appealing a missed base on the last play of an inning.

Frequently asked questions

When does an appeal have to be made?

Before the next pitch, or any play or attempted play. If the play ended the inning, before the pitcher and all infielders leave fair territory.

Is the ball dead during an appeal?

No. Time is not out during an appeal, so runners may try to advance at their own risk.

Sources

Still have a question about Appeal Play? Ask SwingVantage

Related guides & benchmarks

Ready to work on your own swing?

This term is background, not something video measures. Film one swing to find the one thing to work on first — free to start.