Substitution Rules (Re-Entry)
Also known as: re-entry rule, can a player re-enter the game, substitution rule, unannounced substitute, improper substitution
Teams may substitute any time the ball is dead, and the substitute takes the replaced player's spot in the batting order. In MLB, a removed player can never return. NFHS high school rules let a starter re-enter.
MLB Rule 5.10(a) allows substitutions whenever the ball is dead. The manager must tell the umpire-in-chief at once, naming the substitute and his spot in the batting order. Under Rule 5.10(d), a player once removed may not re-enter in any role. If he does and play begins, the player who replaced him is also out of the game. Plays made while he was back in still count.
If no one announces the change, the rules say when the substitute is in. A pitcher is in when he takes the rubber. A batter is in when he steps into the box. A fielder is in when he reaches the position and play starts. A runner is in when he takes the runner's place. The 2026 rules add that a player not on the lineup card cannot be made legal by later play. He must be removed once noticed, though plays made while he was in count.
Other levels differ. In NFHS high school baseball a starter may re-enter, and a 2025 ruling let a starter return as a pitcher. Little League uses mandatory play and, in many games, a continuous batting order. MLB pitchers face extra limits, such as the three-batter minimum. A pitcher may also move to another position only once in the same inning.
Tips by skill level
Coaches, report every change to the plate umpire before play resumes. Give the player's name, batting spot and position.
In high school, plan around re-entry. A starter removed for a pinch-runner may come back in a key spot later.
Example
A pinch-runner replaces a slow catcher in the eighth inning and scores. In the ninth, the team wants the catcher back behind the plate. Under MLB rules he cannot return, so the backup catcher goes in. In an NFHS high school game, the starting catcher could re-enter.
Why it matters
Every lineup change must follow the rules, or a team can lose a player. Re-entry is one of the biggest rule differences between pro and high school play.
Common mistakes
- Not telling the umpire about a substitution.
- Putting a removed player back in under MLB rules. Once play starts, he and his replacement are both out of the game.
- Assuming high school uses MLB's no re-entry rule. NFHS lets starters re-enter.
Frequently asked questions
Can a player re-enter a baseball game?
Not in MLB. Once removed, a player may not return. In NFHS high school baseball, a starter may re-enter.
When is an unannounced substitute officially in the game?
A pitcher when he takes the rubber, a batter when he enters the box, a fielder when he reaches his position and play starts, and a runner when he takes the runner's place.
Sources
Related terms
- Designated Hitter (DH)In high school baseball, NFHS Rule 3-1-4 allows a designated hitter in two ways. The DH can be a tenth starter who bats for one of the nine fielders. Or one of the nine starting fielders can also be the DH, playing defense and batting. In MLB, the DH bats only for the pitcher.
- Mandatory Play and Continuous Batting Order (Little League)Yes. In the Little League regular season, every rostered player present when the game starts must bat at least once. Each must also play at least six defensive outs in the field. In tournament play below the Senior divisions, teams use a continuous batting order, so every player present on the team affidavit bats in turn.
- Courtesy RunnerA courtesy runner goes in for a teammate on base without that teammate leaving the game. Little League allows one for the pitcher and catcher of record. MLB rules ban the practice entirely.
- Three-Batter MinimumUnder MLB's three-batter minimum, every pitcher must face at least three batters in a row, or finish the half-inning, before he can be taken out. The only exception is an injury or illness.
- Batting Out of OrderIf you bat out of order, nothing happens unless the other team appeals. If they appeal while the wrong batter is still up, the right batter steps in and takes over the count. If they appeal after the wrong batter finishes but before the next pitch. The proper batter is out and any advance from the hit is cancelled. Once the next pitch is thrown, the wrong at-bat stands.
- Pregame Plate Meeting (Lineup Cards and Ground Rules)The pregame plate meeting is when the umpires meet both managers at home plate to exchange lineup cards and review ground rules. Once the home team's lineup is handed over, the umpires take charge of the field.
Available in other languages
Related guides & benchmarks
Ready to work on your own swing?
This term is background, not something video measures. Film one swing to find the one thing to work on first — free to start.