Skip to main content
Skip to main content
Advanced

Wins Above Replacement (WAR)

Also known as: fWAR vs bWAR, replacement level, replacement-level player, what is a good WAR, WAR in baseball

Definition

Wins Above Replacement (WAR) estimates how many wins a player adds compared with a freely available replacement player. It combines hitting, baserunning, fielding and position into one number.

WAR asks a simple question. If this player went down, how many wins would the team lose by using a freely available fill-in instead? FanGraphs calls that fill-in a replacement-level player, such as a minor league free agent. For position players, FanGraphs adds batting runs, baserunning runs, fielding runs, a positional adjustment, a league adjustment and replacement runs. It divides the total by runs per win. Its pitcher WAR is built from FIP.

The positional adjustment matters. FanGraphs gives a shortstop about +7.5 runs per full season and a left fielder about −7.5. So two players with the same bat and glove can differ by more than a win. There are several versions. FanGraphs publishes fWAR, Baseball-Reference publishes bWAR (also called rWAR) and Baseball Prospectus has WARP. MLB's glossary notes fWAR uses FIP for pitchers, while bWAR uses runs allowed.

FanGraphs offers rough guides. About 2 WAR is an average full-time regular, and 6 or more is MVP level. It also warns that WAR is an estimate. A 6.4 and a 6.1 cannot really be told apart. Defense adds the most uncertainty.

Tips by skill level

Beginner tip

Use WAR to sort players into rough groups, such as regulars, All-Stars and MVP candidates. Do not use it to split hairs.

Advanced note

When a player's WAR leans on defense, check more than one defensive metric. Defense is the least certain part of the formula.

Example

A slugging first baseman and a slick-fielding shortstop both post 4 WAR. WAR says they helped their teams about equally, through very different skills.

Why it matters

WAR lets you compare a hitter, a fielder and a pitcher on one scale. It is the most common single number for total player value.

Common mistakes

  • Treating small WAR gaps as real. FanGraphs says 6.4 and 6.1 are effectively equal.
  • Mixing fWAR and bWAR in the same comparison.
  • Forgetting that WAR can be negative for a player who performs below replacement level.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good WAR in baseball?

FanGraphs puts an average full-time regular at about 2 WAR, an All-Star at about 4 to 5 and an MVP-level season at 6 or more.

What is the difference between fWAR and bWAR?

FWAR is FanGraphs' version and bWAR is Baseball-Reference's. For pitchers, fWAR uses FIP and bWAR uses runs allowed, so they can differ.

What is a replacement-level player?

FanGraphs describes a player a team could get for almost nothing, such as a minor league free agent. WAR measures value above that level.

Sources

Still have a question about Wins Above Replacement (WAR)? Ask SwingVantage

Related guides & benchmarks

Ready to work on your own swing?

This term is background, not something video measures. Film one swing to find the one thing to work on first — free to start.