Skip to main content
Skip to main content
Intermediate

Replay Review (Manager Challenge)

Also known as: instant replay, manager challenge, replay challenge, replay review rules, crew chief review

Definition

In MLB, replay review lets a manager challenge certain calls. Umpires at the Replay Command Center in New York then decide them on video. A call is changed only with clear and convincing evidence.

MLB's replay system starts with a manager challenge or the crew chief. Each club gets one challenge per game, and two in the All-Star Game and postseason games. A club keeps its challenge if any call it challenged is overturned. To signal, a manager raises his hand right after the play. The umpire then starts a 15-second timer for him to decide.

Replay officials are full-time MLB umpires working shifts at the Replay Command Center in New York. They may change the call, confirm it, or let it stand for lack of clear and convincing evidence. Since 2017 they have aimed to decide within two minutes. If a call changes, they place both teams where they would have been. Their decision is final, and anyone who keeps arguing is ejected.

Not every call can be reviewed. Reviewable calls include home runs, boundary calls, force and tag plays, outfield catches, and certain fair or foul calls. Fair or foul is reviewable only for balls first landing at or beyond the first- or third-base umpire. A crew chief may review a possible home run at any time. From the eighth inning on, he may review any reviewable call himself, or at the request of a manager with no challenges left.

Tips by skill level

Beginner tip

In MLB, watch the manager after a close play. A raised hand means he is thinking about a challenge.

Advanced note

Save the challenge for plays with a clear view. Losing it early leaves nothing for a bigger moment until the eighth inning.

Example

A runner is called out on a stolen base attempt at second. The manager raises his hand, then challenges within the 15 seconds. Replay shows the runner's hand reached the bag before the tag. The call is overturned and the manager keeps his challenge.

Why it matters

It fixes clear mistakes on the biggest plays. Managers must decide quickly which calls are worth a challenge.

Common mistakes

  • Waiting too long to signal. The manager must raise his hand right after the play.
  • Expecting a reversal on a close call. Without clear and convincing evidence, the call stands.
  • Arguing after the replay decision. Anyone who keeps arguing is ejected.

Frequently asked questions

How many challenges does an MLB manager get?

One per game, or two in the All-Star Game and postseason games. He keeps it if any challenged call is overturned.

Who decides replay reviews in MLB?

Replay officials, who are full-time MLB umpires, working at the Replay Command Center in New York.

Sources

Still have a question about Replay Review (Manager Challenge)? Ask SwingVantage

Related guides & benchmarks

Ready to work on your own swing?

This term is background, not something video measures. Film one swing to find the one thing to work on first — free to start.